DK Street Journal

FactSet, Cast as AI's First Casualty, Is Buying Faster Sales Growth With Its Margin

Prompt v1.5

The seat-billed financial data terminal was supposed to be the first thing artificial intelligence deleted. FactSet, which rents that terminal to analysts for roughly $12,000-24,000 a year, instead reported a fifth straight quarter of accelerating subscription growth — organic annual subscription value up 7.1% to $2.49bn — with client and user counts rising and full-year guidance raised, not cut. The catch sits below the top line: operating margin fell from 33.2% to 26.7% as the company spent into its own AI products, so demand is being bought rather than harvested.

The three big investment-data vendors are not one trade. FactSet and Morningstar, both billed by subscription, have rallied hard off May lows; MSCI, which earns a royalty on $2.8trn of exchange-traded fund assets tracking its indices, posted the best numbers of the three — revenue up 12.2%, a 56.2% operating margin — and fell 9% in a month on an expense forecast. Morningstar's growth engine turns out to be credit ratings, not data.

FDSMSCIMORNSPGICSGPSTWDICECMEMKTXNDAQTWInvestment Data TerminalsSubscription Revenue ModelsAI Product SpendingIndex Licensing & ETF FeesCredit Ratings RevenueSoftware Margin Compression
TickerCompanySegmentTrend · 13mo30D1Y
FDSFactSet Research SystemsInvestment Intelligence🌱 Emerging Bull+21.5%−21.7%
MSCIMSCIInvestment Intelligence🟢 Cont. Bull+1.2%−0.3%
MORNMorningstarInvestment Intelligence🔴 Cont. Bear+30.1%−17.2%
SPGIS&P GlobalCredit Ratings🔴 Cont. Bear+0.3%−21.9%
CSGPCoStarReal Estate Data Platforms🔴 Cont. Bear+13.2%−63.4%
STWDStarwood Property TrustCommercial Real Estate Finance🔴 Cont. Bear−1.1%−11.5%
ICEIntercontinental ExchangeDerivatives Trading Venues🔴 Cont. Bear+14.4%−11.7%
CMECMEDerivatives Trading Venues⚠️ Emerging Bear+14.1%+1.9%
MKTXMarketAxessInstitutional Trading Platforms🔴 Cont. Bear+44.1%−13.7%
NDAQNasdaqEquity Exchange⚠️ Emerging Bear+8.7%+4.8%
TWTradeweb MarketsInstitutional Trading Platforms🔴 Cont. Bear+9.1%−18.4%

12-month price & trend

FDS
FactSet Research Systems
300
−1.53 (−0.51%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
FDS 12-month price
Investment Intelligence
MSCI
MSCI
568
+0.60 (+0.10%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
MSCI 12-month price
Investment Intelligence
MORN
Morningstar
215
+1.85 (+0.86%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
MORN 12-month price
Investment Intelligence
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
FDS$11.6B22.4x16.7x4.7x4.4x9.2x8.7x14.1x6.1%
MSCI$46.6B34.1x32.5x13.6x13.2x16.4x16.0x25.1x3.3%
MORN$9.1B21.2x18.6x3.5x3.4x5.5x5.4x12.1x5.4%
SPGI
S&P Global
432
+5.76 (+1.35%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
SPGI 12-month price
Credit Ratings
CSGP
CoStar
32.26
−1.47 (−4.36%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
CSGP 12-month price
Real Estate Data Platforms
STWD
Starwood Property Trust
16.41
−0.15 (−0.91%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
STWD 12-month price
Commercial Real Estate Finance
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
SPGI$139.6B28.6x26.9x8.8x9.4x12.4x13.2x17.9x4.0%
CSGP$13.1B176.3x23.8x3.7x3.5x4.8x4.6x31.1x2.4%
STWD$6.0B24.3x9.8x3.0x2.8x3.9x3.7x16.6x7.3%
ICE
Intercontinental Exchange
159
+1.37 (+0.87%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
ICE 12-month price
Derivatives Trading Venues
CME
CME
271
+3.93 (+1.47%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
CME 12-month price
Derivatives Trading Venues
MKTX
MarketAxess
162
+0.07 (+0.04%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
MKTX 12-month price
Institutional Trading Platforms
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
ICE$87.3B21.9x19.2x6.5x7.9x8.9x10.8x15.3x5.6%
CME$99.2B23.3x22.5x14.7x14.1x17.9x17.3x18.7x4.2%
MKTX$5.8B19.4x20.7x6.7x6.5x9.9x9.6x12.6x2.8%
NDAQ
Nasdaq
98.12
+1.77 (+1.84%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
NDAQ 12-month price
Equity Exchange
TW
Tradeweb Markets
106
+2.80 (+2.71%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
TW 12-month price
Institutional Trading Platforms
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
NDAQ$51.4B26.5x22.3x5.9x8.7x9.9x14.7x18.8x3.8%
TW$22.1B24.8x25.9x10.0x9.4x14.7x13.9x13.3x4.8%

Consensus projections

TickerFY2026EFY2027EFY2028E
FDSRevenue+6.7%+6.1%+6.0%
EPS+4.5%+10.2%+10.4%
MSCIRevenue+12.4%+9.0%+8.7%
EPS+14.3%+14.3%+13.6%
MORNRevenue+10.1%+5.8%+5.8%
EPS+39.1%+14.0%+13.9%
SPGIRevenue−2.9%+5.4%+7.1%
EPS+6.1%+12.5%+12.8%
CSGPRevenue+15.3%+10.3%+11.5%
EPS+62.3%+25.4%+26.9%
STWDRevenue+13.4%+8.8%−22.1%
EPS−1.3%+14.9%+1.4%
ICERevenue+11.5%+5.8%+6.5%
EPS+17.0%+8.8%+11.9%
CMERevenue+7.7%+5.1%+6.5%
EPS+9.6%+5.5%+7.3%
MKTXRevenue+5.6%+6.8%+7.3%
EPS+8.3%+9.2%+10.7%
NDAQRevenue+12.9%+8.9%+8.5%
EPS+20.0%+13.6%+13.3%
TWRevenue+14.0%+11.8%+10.2%
EPS+16.7%+13.8%+13.5%

Forward fiscal years only. Blank means no analyst coverage for that year.

FactSet Research Systems sells the workstation an equity analyst opens each morning: data, models, screens and order workflows, billed per seat at roughly $12,000 to $24,000 a year. That is comfortably below a Bloomberg Terminal's roughly $32,000 per user, and it is precisely the product a competent AI research assistant is supposed to render unnecessary. That fear drove the Norwalk, Connecticut company's shares to multi-year lows earlier this year.

The disclosures point the other way. Organic annual subscription value — the contracted run-rate, the only clean demand measure for a business billed in seats — reached $2.49bn at 31 May, up 7.1%, the fifth consecutive quarter in which that growth rate accelerated. Retention held above 95%, and enterprise renewals lengthened by 30% on average in the quarter. Users and clients rose rather than shrank: 241,352 users at the end of February, a net 1,489 more in three months, plus 98 net new clients. Management raised the fiscal 2026 subscription-value target on 31 March, to $130-160m of net additions from $100-150m, and reaffirmed it on 1 July.

The bill arrives on the margin line

What FactSet is not doing is converting that demand into profit. Quarterly revenue grew 6.4% to $622.9m; operating income fell 14.3%. Operating margin went from 33.2% to 26.7% and gross margin from 52.1% to 49.9%, the arithmetic of embedding AI features into a product whose price per seat cannot rise as fast as the cost of running it. More than 90% of FactSet's fifty largest clients now use four or more of its AI products — adoption that shows up in the subscription line and in the cost line, not yet in earnings.

The shares have repaired about half the de-rating. Against consensus fiscal 2026 earnings of $17.79 a share, FactSet traded at 21.0x a year ago, 11.9x at its 15 May low and 16.9x now — still a fifth below where it started. Consensus models 6.5% revenue growth this year, below the organic subscription growth just reported, an unusual position for a company the market has been treating as structurally impaired. The average sell-side target has been cut toward $305 even as the stock rose to $301.59; Jefferies lifted its target to $253 and kept a Hold.

The one with the best numbers fell

MSCI licenses the benchmarks that index funds are built on, so it is paid a fee on assets, not on analysts. Its asset-based fee run rate hit a record $948m, up 25%, on roughly $40bn of second-quarter ETF inflows and $2.8trn of ETF assets tracking its indices. Revenue grew 12.2% to $867m at a 56.2% operating margin — the strongest of the three by both measures. The shares fell 10.1% in the 21 July session anyway, because the company raised its full-year expense guidance to $1,340-1,370m from $1,305-1,335m for the First Street acquisition and incentive pay. That single day is the entire month's decline. The result is a stock unchanged over twelve months on a forward multiple of 28.8x, identical to a year ago, while consensus 2026 earnings for it rose about 14% — a full year of growth accruing to the holder as nothing. Trailing, 31x compares with a ten-year average near 41.6x. The soft spot is sustainability data, where management guided net new sales to roughly zero for two quarters; private-assets subscriptions are growing past 16%.

Morningstar, the smallest at $8.0bn, is the one whose improvement is real and whose source is misread. Revenue rose 9.6% to $663.2m and operating margin widened from 20.7% to 24.2%. But Morningstar Credit — the DBRS ratings business — grew 23.4% to $104.9m on structured-finance issuance and supplied about a third of all revenue growth from a sixth of revenue, while PitchBook, its seat-billed private-markets platform, grew 4.9% amid corporate churn. The fastest-improving investment-data company is being carried by the debt-issuance cycle.

What the month actually was

Morningstar's 24% month is one gap: the sessions spanning its 28 July results moved the stock 16.4%, and stripping that plus its next-best day leaves about 2%. FactSet's is not — it round-tripped a July spike, then built 14.6% through August, and even without its two best August sessions retains roughly 4% of drift. On 19 August, when FactSet gained 5.7% with no company news beyond a routine $1.16 dividend, thirty-year Treasury yields fell 10 basis points to 5.18% and the S&P 500 rose 0.4%. That is multiple repair on a long-duration subscription stream, not a fresh disclosure.

Underneath all three, the industry pool is still growing: global spending on financial market data rose 6.5% to a record $49.2bn in 2025, with AI integration cited as a driver of demand rather than a substitute for it.

The setup

Where it stands — FactSet's subscription growth is accelerating while its margin compresses; MSCI's numbers are the group's best and its shares the worst. Would confirm — FactSet's fiscal fourth-quarter organic subscription value growth prints at or above 7.1% in September. Would invalidate — Adjusted operating margin lands below the reaffirmed 34-35.5% range, or client and user counts turn negative. Watch next — FactSet reports fiscal fourth-quarter and full-year results in late September; MSCI reports third-quarter results in October. Valuation — FactSet 19.5x trailing and 16.9x forward, against 21.0x on the same estimate a year ago and 11.9x in May.